A Roman Catholic Parish Serving:

Penn Yan, Dundee, Naples, Prattsburgh,

Rushville, and Stanley


Saint Michael's Church
Penn Yan, NY
Parish Founded: 1850
Current Church: 1902


Saint Michael's Catholic School
Penn Yan, NY
School Founded: 1882
Grades: PreK-5


Saint Patrick's Church
Prattsburg, NY
Parish Founded: 1860
Current Church: 1868


Saint Januarius' Church
Naples, NY
Parish Founded: 1876
Current Church: 1964

2023 Vocations poster
Orzels working on Pflaum weekly lesson
LaChapelle Shrine
1 of 4 Grandma's Kitchen
4 of 4 of Grandma's Kitchen
previous arrow
next arrow

Saint Theresa’s Church, 1876-2019

The signs of the times have caused Saint Theresa’s, an example of the old country churches that once dotted America, to be closed as of 6/30/2019. Those signs are fewer men becoming priests, younger families choosing not to attend Mass and the exorbitant cost of major repairs to the church building. An engineering study conducted by the diocese prohibited Mass to continue to be prayed within the church. Mass was moved to the hall of the rectory for a short time, until the final Mass on 6/30/2019, held in the neighboring Stanley Fire Hall.
Highlights of St. Theresa’s:
It was built for the newly arrived Irish immigrants who were working on the railroad.
The church was constructed at a cost of $4,500 dollars.
The corner stone was laid by Bishop McQuaid the first Bishop of Rochester.
It was the sister church of St. Mary’s, Rushville.
Its neighboring rectory was constructed in 1882.
Its golden anniversary was celebrated in 1926 with the confirmation of 32 candidates from the parish.
The stained glass windows were a donation from the parishioners and priests who lived, worked, and celebrated the Eucharist in Stanley.
One of three cemeteries in Our Lady of the Lakes is located near St. Theresa’s.

Some of the images of St. Theresa’s closing Mass, procession to view the sanctuary and luncheon are here for your enjoyment and memories.


Here is the link for the history of the first 100 years of St. Mary’s, Rushville, and St. Theresa’s, Stanley.

Copyright © 2024 Our Lady of the Lakes   |   Scroll to top ↑
Roman Catholic Diocese of Rochester   ·   1150 Buffalo Road   ·   Rochester, NY 14624
DOR Safe Environment Info   ·   www.dor.org